Skip to content
codebrix

Buying guide

Choosing a web development company: questions, red flags and a scoring sheet

To choose a web development company, write a short brief first, shortlist three to five firms whose live work you have checked, ask the same questions on every call, then score each proposal on scope clarity, the people doing the work, ownership, process and price. Start with one paid milestone. The cheapest quote is often the vaguest one.

Shortlist
3 to 5 companies
Compare on
Weighted scoring, not price alone
Check yourself
Their live sites on a phone
Start with
One paid milestone

Updated · By the Codebrix team

Start with your own brief

Companies can only quote accurately against what you tell them. If you send five firms a two-line email, you get five quotes for five different websites and no way to compare them. Spend an afternoon on a one or two-page brief: what the site is for, who it is for, the pages and features you need, integrations, who writes the content, your budget range and your date. Our website brief template has every question laid out.

Send the same brief to everyone. It is the single biggest thing you can do to make proposals comparable, and the way a company responds to it is your first signal about how they work.

Build a shortlist you can trust

  1. Find candidates through referrals from founders you trust, sites you admire (check the footer credit or ask the owner), and directories, in that order.
  2. Open at least three live sites each company has built. Use them on your phone. Fill in a form. Check that the pages load quickly and nothing jumps around.
  3. Run one of their sites through Google's free PageSpeed Insights. You are not looking for a perfect score, just evidence that performance was taken seriously.
  4. Look for work similar in size to yours. A company that only builds large enterprise portals may not want, or price well for, a six-page site.
  5. Ask for one or two past clients you can speak to, and actually call them.
  6. Cut the list to three to five. More than that and you will not have time to compare properly.

Questions to ask on the first call

Ask every company the same questions and write the answers down. Vague answers are an answer too.

People

  • Who will design and who will write the code? Can I speak to them before signing?
  • Is any of the work subcontracted? To whom?
  • Who is my day-to-day contact, and how quickly do they usually reply?

Process

  • How often will I see working progress, not just designs or reports?
  • How do you handle a change I ask for halfway through?
  • What testing happens before launch: which browsers, which devices, who signs it off?

Ownership

  • Whose accounts will the domain, hosting, code repository and CMS sit in?
  • Do I own the code and design files outright once paid? Is that in the contract?
  • Are there theme, plugin or software licences in your name that I would need to replace if we part ways?

Money and after launch

  • Is the price fixed? What is excluded? How are payments split?
  • What happens if the project runs late on your side?
  • Is there a bug-fix period after launch? What do changes cost after that?
  • If we stop working together, what does handover include?

Red flags that should end the conversation

  • A price arrives before they have asked you a single question about the project.
  • They will not let you speak to the person who will build the site.
  • Hosting or the domain will be registered in the company's name 'to make things easier'.
  • They ask for most or all of the money upfront.
  • The portfolio has screenshots but no live links, or the live sites are slow and broken on a phone.
  • They promise first-page Google rankings or a guaranteed number of leads. Nobody can promise that.
  • The proposal has no list of exclusions, so everything you assumed was included becomes a debate later.
  • They agree to every feature and every date without pushing back on anything.

How to compare proposals: a scoring table

Score each proposal from 1 to 5 on each row, multiply by the weight, and add up. The weights below are a sensible default for a marketing website. Change them to suit you, but decide the weights before you read the proposals so the price does not bias everything else.

Weights add up to 100. Maximum score is 500.
CriterionWeightWhat a 5 looks likeWhat a 1 looks like
Scope clarity20Every page and feature listed, exclusions stated, assumptions written downA paragraph and a price
People15Named designer and developer you have spoken to'Our team' with no names
Ownership and exit15All accounts in your name, IP assigned, handover describedHosting and code held by the company
Process and visibility15Weekly working demos, shared board, named contactUpdates 'as needed'
Relevant work10Live, fast sites similar to yours, references you calledScreenshots only
Performance and SEO basics10Speed, metadata, redirects and analytics in scope'We can optimise later'
After launch5Written bug-fix period and a clear rate for changesNothing stated
Price and payment terms10Fixed, milestone-based, paid after deliveryLarge deposit, hourly with no cap

If two proposals score within about 10 per cent of each other, take the one whose people you would rather work with for the next few months. If the highest scorer is far above your budget, ask them what a smaller first release would look like rather than defaulting to the cheapest.

Read the price properly

Two quotes that look far apart often cover different work. Before comparing numbers, mark each item below as included, excluded or not mentioned in every proposal.

ItemWhy it changes the price
Content writingCopy for 10 pages is real work; someone has to do it
Stock photos and iconsLicences cost money and someone has to choose them
Original design vs a templateCustom design takes longer but fits your brand
CMS and trainingEditing your own pages needs set-up and a walkthrough
IntegrationsCRM, booking, payments and email tools each take time
Redirects from an old siteSkipping them can lose existing search traffic
Analytics and consentTracking set-up and a cookie banner where needed
Rounds of revisionsUnlimited revisions usually mean a padded price
Hosting and domain costsUsually paid by you to the provider, separately
Post-launch supportFree fix period length and the cost after it

For what typically drives website prices, read our website cost guide for India. If you are still deciding whether you need a company at all, compare the trade-offs in agency vs freelancer.

Make the final decision with a small first step

Whoever wins your scoring, do not sign the whole project in one go if you can avoid it. Start with a paid discovery or the design milestone. Within two or three weeks you will know whether their questions were good, whether progress was visible and whether they handled feedback well. If yes, sign the next milestone. If not, you keep the work and move on.

That is how we prefer to start too. Codebrix publishes its process and indicative pricing, sends a written fixed-price proposal within two to four days of a discovery call, and lets you begin with a single milestone. See what is included in our web development service.

Frequently asked questions

How many web development companies should I get quotes from?

Three to five is usually enough. Fewer and you have little to compare; more and you will not have time to read every proposal properly, check live work and call references. Send all of them the same written brief so the quotes cover the same project and can be compared fairly.

Should I just pick the cheapest proposal?

Only if it scores well on scope, people, ownership and process too. The cheapest quote is often the one with the shortest scope, the most exclusions or the least testing, and the difference comes back as change requests. Score every proposal on the same weighted criteria and decide the weights before you look at prices.

What questions reveal the most about a web development company?

Ask who will write the code and whether you can speak to them, whose accounts the hosting and repository will sit in, how often you will see working progress, and what is excluded from the price. The specificity of the answers tells you more than any portfolio.

Is it a red flag if a company asks for a deposit?

A modest deposit to book time is common. The warning sign is a large share of the total paid before any work exists, or the full amount upfront. Prefer payment per delivered and approved milestone, so each payment matches something you have seen working.

How do I check a web company's quality if I am not technical?

Use their live sites on your own phone, fill in forms and see if anything breaks or jumps. Run one site through Google PageSpeed Insights. Call a past client and ask what went wrong and how it was handled. Then start with one small paid milestone and judge the working software you receive.

Should a web development company guarantee Google rankings?

No. Nobody controls Google's rankings, so a guarantee is a sign the company is overselling. A good company will build the site so search engines can crawl and understand it, set up metadata, redirects and analytics, and explain how progress will be measured after launch.

Sources

  • Web development

    A web development company in India that builds on Next.js

    Web development company in India building fast Next.js marketing sites and web apps. Fixed quotes, a demo every week, and you own all of the code.

    Read more
  • Template

    A website brief template you can fill in this afternoon

    A free website brief template to fill in today: goals, audience, pages, features, design, SEO, budget and timeline, with good vs vague answer examples.

    Read more
  • Buying guide

    Agency vs freelancer for website development: which should build your site?

    Agency vs freelancer for website development: an honest look at cost, risk, speed and ownership, with a comparison table and a checklist before you sign.

    Read more
  • Cost guide

    How much does website development cost in India?

    Website development cost in India, explained: what moves the price, our indicative ranges, recurring costs, hidden costs and how to get a fixed quote.

    Read more
  • Website redesign

    Website redesign services that protect the search traffic you already have

    Website redesign services that audit first, map every URL and 301-redirect old pages so the search traffic you have earned is carried to the new site.

    Read more
Estimate Call WhatsApp